Showing posts with label jury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jury. Show all posts

Sunday, March 29, 2026

i have been chosen

There's an old joke that goes: "You better be honest, because you wouldn't want your fate to be put in the hands of someone too dumb to get out of jury duty."

I have been called to report for jury duty three times. The first was about twenty years ago. I woke up that morning not feeling well, but I went to the Montgomery County Court House anyway. I sat in the jury marshaling room in a veritable daze. I was called to a courtroom with a group of fellow prospective jurors, but I was not selected for the jury. I returned to the jury marshaling room and was soon dismissed for the day. I drove home, feeling like crap. Later that day, I was admitted to the hospital with cellulitis.

My second time being called for jury duty was a doozy! I was selected as an alternate on a federal grand jury. I was told that, with a pool of 22 jurors, it was very rare that the alternates were ever called. Two weeks later, I was called to federal grand jury duty. I served every Thursday for two years. It was an experience that I would not wish on anyone. (If you are so inclined, you can read about my time as a member of a federal grand jury HERE.)

The third time I was called for jury duty was this morning. I woke up at the usual time, but instead of driving to work, I drove to the Montgomery County Court House, a trip I hadn't taken in over twenty years. I parked and followed several other folks who had parked in the designated garage at the same time I did. Obviously, we were all there to fulfill our civic duty. Me and my small group trudged around sidewalk construction as we silently made our way up the steep incline of Swede Street. We crossed the street and followed the large directional signs, most of which were no more details than a bold black arrow and the word "JURORS" in equally as bold capital letters. We all filed in through the heavy wooden doors, where we were immediately ordered to empty our pockets of any metal object and then pass through a metal detector. Surprisingly, no one set the mechanism off. I collected my belongings from the small plastic tray. The "officer" heading up the metal detection operation wasn't giving up my insulated water bottle too quickly. He shook it and squinted at it and shook it some more. Satisfied that I was not transporting anything that posed a threat to the building and its occupants, He handed the bottle over to me without explanation.

I found a seat in the so-called "Juror's Lounge." Despite it's name there was no jazz combo, no cocktail waitresses and no bowls of mixed nuts. Instead, the room featured several small round tables usually found in a shopping mall food court, each surrounded by some very uncomfortable-looking chairs. I sat at a table in silence. As a matter of fact, everyone sat in silence. Soon, a woman announced that we would be assembling in the jury marshaling room. Everyone was required to present their jury summons and a photo ID. One by one, we were ushered into the room, where another woman seated behind a plexiglas shield scanned a barcode on the jury summons. By the time everyone had passed through the doors and selected a seat, the room was about half full. At fifteen minutes past 8 o'clock (the required time to report), a few stragglers wandered in.

The first woman made some brief introductory announcements and told us that a judge would be stopping by to thank us for coming in and serving (as though there was a choice). As promised, said judge arrived and addressed the jury pool as though he was a comedian entertaining a club full of patrons with a "tight 5." He sprinkled his spiel with a few corny jokes as he explained the importance of juries and the importance of serving on a jury and the importance of democracy and the importance of a few more things I don't recall.

The first woman reported that there was one trial on the schedule and a decision for jury requirements would be made shortly. In the meantime, we were given a "break." She turned on two large televisions and we were forced to watch a couple renovating a home on HGTV. A few people in the room worked silently on laptops. Others, who came prepared, opened dog-eared paperback books and read silently. One woman, seated two rows in front of me, pulled a large hardback book from a tote bag resting on the floor by her feet. It was a cookbook. From my vantage point, I could see the glossy photos of prepared meals on beautifully appointed tables as she turned the pages. I thought it was an odd choice of reading material to pass the time while waiting to see if jury service was in one's future... but who am I to judge? I did not read or watch the home renovations. I dozed.

Over two hours later, the woman announced that another judge would be down to talk to us. A collective grimace waved through the room. Within a few minutes, a second judge introduced himself to the room and expounded on the first judge's sentiment. This judge, however, dispelled some myths about jury service and the whole judicial process. He noted that all of the "surefire" ways of getting out of jury duty that you heard on social media are baloney. Changing subjects, he explained that the case on the schedule today was set to be a jury trial... until it was settled before jury selection began. The overall sense of relief in the room was palpable. "Hmm...," the judge questioned rhetorically, "maybe I should have led with that." Then he added, "I didn't because I didn't want to get trampled by the rush to the door." That said, we were dismissed.

Everyone, traced the same path back to the parking garage via the steep hill and the sidewalk construction. I located my car and joined the line of cars inching towards the exit. An attendant took my parking ticket and the county-issued "free parking" voucher. As the gate rose, allowing access to freedom, the parking lot attendant smiled and informed me that the strip clubs in town open at noon, so I still had plenty of time.

Yes sir. That's what he said, because some people have to always say something.

I wished him "a good day" and made a right turn on to Ridge Pike towards home.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

good morning, worm your honor


Last week, while all of you patriots were performing your civic duty, I was watching a 55 year-old rerun of Make Room for Daddy, a show I don't particularly like. But, given the choice, I was glad to have endured a half hour of the insufferable Danny Thomas – hamming it up and mugging for the camera – than to flick a little lever in a voting booth and pretend that my vote makes a difference.

I have not voted since Barack Obama became president the first time. Actually, after the embarrassing debacle that was the 2000 presidential election, with its lengthy recounts, ballot tampering and infamous "hanging chads," I swore I would never vote again. But, I gave in to some heart-stirring "Land of the Free and Home of the Brave" sentiment and voted in several more elections over the next eight years. 

Until that one day.

It was early in 2008. I came home from work, slung my jacket on the back of a living room chair (much to the on-going dismay of Mrs. Pincus) and began to leisurely rifle through a stack of the day's mail. Among the catalogs and utility bills, was an ominous yet important-looking envelope. It was addressed to me and featured a governmental return address in the top left-hand corner. I frowned. I slipped my index finger under the sealed flap, carefully sliding it along and tearing a neat opening along the fold. I removed the machine-folded single sheet of paper and began to read. I scanned the first few sentences following the cold salutation. When I hit the fearful gist of the communique, I involuntarily reacted.

"Dammit!," I uttered aloud, "Jury duty!"

But this was no ordinary jury duty. No sir. This was not of the "One Day. One Trial" variety. This was a call from the federal government. I was to report as part of a pool of prospects for service on a Federal Grand Jury.

On my designated day, I assembled, along with 74 others selected from the registered voters representing seven counties in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. A low murmur filled the cavernous marshaling room of the federal courthouse, as numbers were called and the potential jurors were chosen. A grand jury is comprised of 22 jurors and two alternates. The alternates do not have to report for jury duty until one of the actual jurors is excused for valid reason. As the selections were made and my chances of being chosen slimmed, several of those already picked conferred with a court officer. Obviously they pleaded a convincing case of family hardship and were instantly excused. Replacement alternates had to be chosen. My number was the last one called. In the immortal words of Maxwell Smart: "Missed it by that much."

I was told by an official that, as an alternate, it was very unlikely that I would ever have to report. 

Six weeks later, another ominous-looking envelope was delivered to my house. When I read the contents, I, once again, involuntarily reacted. Only this time, I yelled instead of uttered.

"FUCK!," I screamed with enough vocal power to rattle some dishes in the kitchen.

A Federal Grand Jury convenes once a week to hear testimony (or parts of on-going testimony) from witnesses questioned by a federal district attorney. There are no attorneys and no judge. There is a District Attorney, the members of the jury and a court reporter. After enough evidence is presented to satisfy the D.A., the jury discusses and rehashes until a decision to indict (or not to indict) is reached. Sure it sounds interesting, like something right out of Perry Mason or Law & Order, but, believe me, it isn't. It's boring. Witnesses are boring. Testimony is tedious. People are inarticulate and downright stupid. Some District Attorneys think they are auditioning for a role in Inherit the Wind. But mostly, it's monotonous. And I sat through that bullshit for the initial term of eighteen months — plus a six-month extension — for a grand fucking total of two fucking years. Every Thursday, I was excused from work to sit in a federal courthouse and listen to a parade of morons get schooled in the ways of the law. And that applied to both sides of the witness box.

Some of my jury mates had never been to the "big city" of Philadelphia in their lives and were bewildered by buildings taller than three stories and the fact that people wore shoes all the time. One guy sat in the first row of seats and read the newspaper during testimony. One guy rattled and crinkled a cellophane bag of candy as witnesses spoke. Another guy slammed his head against a rear wall as he dozed off to sleep. These are the people who are deciding your fate, Mr. Criminal, so you best keep to the straight and narrow. 

The jury on which I served heard predominately cases of fraud (identity theft, credit card scams, bad counterfeiting), although, due to overflow and crowding, we sometimes heard cases of another nature. One of those non-fraud cases involved an online child-pornography distribution ring. During some of the most disgusting, stomach-churning testimony, the DA asked if we would like to see examples of images that were seized. The jury collectively cringed. One guy — the bag rattler, as a matter of fact — cleared his throat and suggested that we should view the photos to help us decide on an indictment. The assistant foreperson  — an outspoken young lady — shot up out of her seat and pointed an accusing finger at her fellow juror.

"We don't need to see any of that!," she spit, "I don't need to see every bad check that was passed in a fraud case!"

I did, however, learn a few valuable lessons from serving on a Grand Jury:
  1. Never ever ever ever buy a used car. There is an excellent chance that the odometer was turned back. More than excellent.
  2. Don't trust anyone who works in a bank. For the price of a few bouquets of flowers and a dinner or two, tellers are giving out your bank account information like it's Halloween candy.
  3. Criminals get caught because they are greedy. If everyone who ever perpetrated a crime would have quit after one time, satisfied with whatever they got, they would have gotten away with it. It's when they want more and want it faster  — that's when they get caught.

And the most important lesson I learned? If you don't want to be subjected to the insipid task of jury duty (federal or otherwise), keep your name off of the voter list from which potential jurors are culled. And how does one stay off of voter lists? By not voting, of course.

Believe me, this nifty little certificate ain't worth it. Neither is voting.